At a time when CMS is actively assessing re-certification for select arbitrators, also known as IDR entities (IDREs), a new investigation by STAT News finds that arbitrators are profiting from a system with little accountability or oversight, siding with providers in more than 80% of cases while employers and patients absorb billions in costs from inflationary IDR awards.
STAT’s reporting highlights how IDREs “perform their work largely in secret, with little accountability or oversight. And their decisions are effectively set in stone, after multiple judges ruled that courts can’t overturn them.”
One company, iMPROve, faced financial uncertainty before becoming an IDRE. “Three years later, iMPROve boasts a 70% profit margin, almost as high as that of tech giant Nvidia. Its revenue has grown 13-fold. The turnaround is thanks to the company’s new government-backed role: picking winners in high-stakes payment disputes between health care providers and health insurers.”
Highlights from the full investigation are included below. To read the full story, click here.
The binding nature of IDR determinations demands greater transparency and accountability – both of which are missing in oversight of IDREs.
- “‘The [arbitrators] are essentially operating as mini gods, above the law, so to speak, from regulators and the courts,’ said Melissa Bartlett, senior vice president of health policy at The ERISA Industry Committee [ERIC], an advocacy group for large employers, which contends the law is raising the cost of health care and must be reined in.”
- “‘Looking at the decisions, it is very hard to understand how they are being made,’ said Loren Adler, a health economist with the Brookings Institution. Not only that, it’s impossible to identify the individuals making these highly consequential calls. Unlike in the legal system, where judges’ names and titles are public, that’s never revealed in No Surprises Act.”
- A former arbitration employee said, “she became disturbed by how similar the [IDR] documentation from providers was. She said the whole thing ‘felt kind of dirty’ because filings from different providers matched word for word, seemingly written by lawyers and middlemen rather than doctors. ‘It almost felt scammy that these companies would be clearly hiring high-pressure lawyers who know what to say,’ she said.”
Arbitrators are profiting from a system where the incentives encourage them to side with providers.
- “The arbitrators’ shocking financial results add to the reasons to question their work. They’re siding with providers in over 80% of cases, which may be in part to drum up more business, since providers file the majority of disputes.”
- “And they’re awarding clinicians massive sums of money — multiple times what they made before the law took effect in 2022. A common spine surgery that typically costs $1,400 in network now fetches $34,000 in arbitration at the median, with some providers getting over $100,000. Doctors are making $61,000 for breast reduction surgery via arbitration, a procedure whose in-network rate is $1,420.”
- “One study found that arbitrators that favor providers in over 90% of disputes tend to have the highest case loads, suggesting that the parties pick them based on their previous experience.”
Urgent reforms to IDR are needed to protect employers and families who are footing the bill.
- “The lopsided outcomes and immense, ever-growing costs are putting pressure on Congress to rein in the arbitrators and at least one federal legislative proposal seeks to do away with them entirely. Academics, employer groups, and researchers warn that, eventually, everyone who buys health insurance will feel the effects in the form of higher premiums and out-of-pocket costs.”
- Large employers like Microsoft, Halliburton, Quest Diagnostics, and DICK’S Sporting Goods are urging members of Congress to address the IDR affordability crisis. “They wrote in a July letter that arbitrators are issuing excessive, unreasonable payment awards that are ultimately borne by employers and employees.”
- “While a congressional fix would have the most impact, the agencies that oversee arbitration can make improvements on their own, starting with simply demanding more transparency into the ‘black box’ of the arbitration process, Brown University’s [Lindsey] Murtagh said.”
- “To that end, [Ranking Member] Pallone recently sent letters to six of the arbitrators, asking for information on things like how they train their staff, their dispute volume, financial relationships, and use of artificial intelligence.”
Read the full STAT investigation here. For more about the cost impact of arbitration, click here.
Recent Comments